Retention1 min read

    9% of people who pay once come back. One has asked 33 times.

    Of 421 people who have paid for an answer, 38 have paid for more than one. The single most frequent asker has sent 33 paid questions to the same coach, which is a relationship rather than a transaction.

    9%

    of askers come back

    33

    questions from one person

    421

    askers

    Who is writing this: Lucy Chen, who runs Nudge. I read these figures out of our own payments rather than collecting them from anywhere else. Captured payments grouped by asker email, counting people with more than one paid answer, 2026-10-18.

    Who this is for: coaches working out whether a paid question is a one-off or the start of something.

    The headline is the wrong way round

    A 9% repeat rate sounds low until you notice what the product is. Most people pay to resolve one decision, and when it is resolved they leave. That is the question being answered properly, not churn.

    The 38 are worth more than the rate suggests

    Repeat askers return to the same coach rather than browsing. The person at 33 questions has effectively retained their coach by the message, without a package, a contract or a call in the calendar.

    What produces a second question

    Almost always an answer that opened something rather than closing it. An answer that ends with the next decision named is the one that gets asked again; an answer that wraps the topic up neatly tends to be the last.

    Why this is not a subscription

    Nudge has 4 live subscriptions against thousands of one-time tiers. Repeat buying here is not a plan someone signed up for, it is the same person choosing to pay again, which is a much better signal and a much worse recurring-revenue line.

    Where this is weak

    Askers are matched by email, so one person using two addresses counts twice and the real repeat rate is slightly higher than 9%.

    More from the data

    Put a price on the answers you already give

    Every figure in these posts came from coaches doing exactly that.