Do people rate expensive answers more harshly?
A bit, in the middle. Answers between $30 and $60 averaged 4.67 and were five stars 83% of the time, against 4.82 for the $15 to $30 band. Above $60 every rating was five stars, but there are only 14 of them.
4.80
average rating under $15
5.00
average rating over $60
211
rated answers
Who is writing this: Lucy Chen, who runs Nudge. I read these figures out of our own payments rather than collecting them from anywhere else. Captured payments joined to their questions where the asker left a rating, bucketed by amount paid, 2026-10-18. 211 rated payments in total.
Who this is for: any coach who has talked themselves out of raising their price.
The numbers
Under $15: 46 ratings, 4.80 average, 91% five stars. $15 to $30: 109 ratings, 4.82, 89%. $30 to $60: 42 ratings, 4.67, 83%. Over $60: 14 ratings, 5.00, 100%.
The dip is real but small
Going from the $15 to $30 band up to the $30 to $60 band costs about 0.15 of a star and six percentage points of five-star rate. On 42 ratings that is a few people, so it is a signal rather than a finding, and it is worth about one extra careful paragraph.
Why the top band is not proof that expensive is safe
Fourteen ratings is nothing, and the coaches charging over $60 are mostly the ones who have answered hundreds of questions. The band is measuring experience as much as price.
The practical read
Raising a price does not meaningfully anger people. The dip suggests that above roughly $30 an answer starts being judged as a piece of work rather than a favour, which mostly means saying what you would do and why, rather than being warm about it.
Where this is weak
Only about 38% of paid answers get rated, and happier askers rate more often, so every number here sits above the true average.
