Paid question platforms compared
11 head-to-head comparisons, on the three things that actually differ: what the platform takes, how long you have to reply, and how the money reaches you.
Every competitor figure is dated on its page, and says whether it was read from their own site or from research. Check theirs before relying on ours.
Head to head with Nudge
| Platform | What they take | Reply window |
|---|---|---|
| Nudge | 10%, coach keeps 90% | 7 days, or the asker is not charged |
| Topmate | The commission is 10% of earnings, plus transaction fees their pricing page lists at 2% to 6% | Not stated on the pricing page |
| Popcall | The creator share is 80% and Popcall takes 20% | 2 days to reply in order to get paid |
| PayDM | The creator earns 80% of every message | 8 days, or the asker is refunded automatically |
| Minnect | The expert share is 80% of every transaction | Not stated on the homepage; they advertise a 94% response rate |
| Brillay | The platform fee is 8% when a follower pays for work, and 5% on tips and funding goals | Creator sets the delivery time |
| PaidDM | A 15% platform fee plus 4.4% and $0.30 processing, charged only when the creator replies within 48 hours | 48 hours |
| Clarity.fm | Commission was reported at 15% in 2012 and is not restated on their current pages | Not applicable: calls are scheduled, billed by the minute |
| EveryExpert | The fee is 9% per transaction plus Stripe processing | Not stated publicly |
| Intro | The take is 10% when a booking comes through the expert's own referral link, and 30% through Intro's own app or website | Not applicable: calls are scheduled |
| Cameo | Talent keep 75%, and Apple takes 30% first on bookings made in the iOS app | Set per talent, typically a few days |
| DialMe | The creator keeps 80% | Not stated publicly |
No ranking here on purpose. Each page says when the other platform is the better pick.
Looking for an alternative to something else
- Nudge as a Cameo alternative
- Nudge as a Stan Store alternative
- Nudge as a Patreon alternative
- Nudge as a Kajabi alternative
- Nudge as a Teachable alternative
- Nudge as a Substack alternative
- Nudge as a Skool alternative
- Nudge as a Linktree alternative
- Nudge as a Beacons alternative
- Nudge as a Ko-fi alternative
- Nudge as a Mighty Networks alternative
- Nudge as a ManyChat alternative
- Nudge as a Calendly alternative
- Nudge as a Clarity alternative
- Nudge as a Intro alternative
- Nudge as a Cold email alternative
Common questions
Which paid question platform takes the smallest cut?
Of the platforms compared here, Brillay takes 8% and EveryExpert 9%. Nudge keeps 10%. Popcall, PayDM, Minnect and DialMe each take 20%, and PaidDM takes 15% plus processing. Figures are dated on each page.
What is the difference between paid questions and paid calls?
A paid question is answered asynchronously, in writing or as a recording, with nothing to schedule. A paid call is a booked slot, often billed by the minute. Clarity and Intro are call platforms; Nudge, PaidDM, PayDM and Brillay are question platforms; Popcall and Minnect do both.
Which platform should a coach pick?
It depends on what you sell and how fast you reply. Each page here has a 'pick them instead if' section saying plainly when the other platform is the better choice, because a comparison that always concludes the same way is not worth reading.
